News

MY PASSION IS

TO RESTORE YOUR BODY'S

NATURAL HEALING POWER

News

Noticias

News News

Why a large emergency-department acupuncture trial did not show an overall pain advantage

8:03 pm 1 November 2026 0 Comments

When pain strikes suddenly and you end up in an emergency department, acupuncture is not the first thing most people expect to be offered. A large US trial tested whether adding it helps, and found no clear overall advantage in pain at one month. It also showed how hard it can be for people to attend follow-up treatment, which is part of the story.

What the researchers did

This was a pragmatic randomised trial, meaning it was designed to reflect real-world care rather than tightly controlled conditions. It was run at an academic emergency department in the United States (Duke University) with a linked acupuncture clinic, and first published online on 1 December 2025 in Pain Medicine.

Adults who arrived with acute musculoskeletal pain in the neck, back or limbs that had lasted seven days or less could take part. Screening ran from February 2020 to April 2023, and of 2,781 people screened, 599 were enrolled.

They were randomly assigned to one of two groups. The acupuncture group (410 people, 68.4%) received acupuncture from licensed acupuncturists in the emergency department, then were offered twice-weekly sessions at a follow-up clinic for one month, in addition to usual care. The comparison group (189 people, 31.6%) received usual care only. The groups were not equal in size.

General acupuncture, no emergency setting
Illustrative image. AI-generated editorial illustration.

What they found

Pain levels were the same at the start, at an average of 7.1 in both groups. After one month, average pain was 3.8 in the usual-care group and 3.2 in the acupuncture group. The authors describe the pain outcomes at one month as similar between the groups, and the trial did not find an overall between-group difference in pain.

Both groups improved a lot over the month, which is what often happens with new, acute pain. That makes it harder for any added treatment to show a difference.

A major practical finding was about attendance. In the acupuncture group, 178 of 410 people (43.4%) could not attend the follow-up clinic sessions, and they gave time and financial constraints as reasons. That means a large share of the people assigned to acupuncture did not receive the full course that was planned.

The researchers then ran an additional analysis. People who attended six or more acupuncture sessions (121 people, 20.2% of everyone enrolled) had significantly greater pain improvement than those who attended fewer sessions (478 people, 79.8%). The authors conclude that better access to outpatient acupuncture may be needed to manage pain more effectively.

What this does and does not show

The main, randomised comparison did not show that acupuncture reduced pain more than usual care alone. The result about people who attended six or more sessions is different in kind. This was an exploratory analysis, and attendance was not randomly assigned. People who can attend many sessions may differ in many ways from those who cannot, such as their work flexibility, income, transport, pain severity or how well they were recovering anyway. Those differences, rather than the needles, could explain why they did better. The analysis therefore cannot show that more sessions cause better outcomes.

This does not mean acupuncture has no role, and it does not mean it works. What it shows is that, in a busy emergency department setting in the United States, offering acupuncture on top of usual care did not lead to a clearly different average pain level at one month, and that practical barriers were common.

Other reasons the findings may not apply to you:

  • The trial was run in one United States setting, where costs, insurance and health systems differ from Australia.
  • It enrolled people with acute pain of up to a week, and may say little about pain that has lasted for months.
  • The summary does not describe a sham comparison, so the study cannot tell whether needling itself matters.
  • Average results hide individual differences, and some people may have gained more or less than the average.

This article is general education, not advice. Severe pain, pain after a significant injury, or pain with other symptoms such as chest pain or weakness should be assessed urgently by a doctor, or call 000 in an emergency.

Questions to ask

  • What is the likely cause of my pain, and what is the usual outlook for improvement over the next few weeks without any added treatment?
  • If a course of treatment is suggested, how many visits would it need, what would it cost, and can I realistically attend them?
  • How will we decide whether a treatment is helping, and when should I come back if my pain is not settling?

Source: Acupuncture for acute musculoskeletal pain in the emergency department and clinic: a pragmatic randomized trial DOI: 10.1093/pm/pnaf165

AI-generated editorial illustration. The scene is fictional and does not depict a study participant or demonstrate treatment effectiveness. This article summarises published research in our own words and is general information, not personal health advice.

Comments are disabled

News

Buscar
Recent entries
Categories

News